Home Truths

18/11/2011 at 3:42 pm 3 comments

This week the Bank of England published its quarterly Inflation Report, and its Governor highlighted the fact that misery in Europe will hit growth in Britain too. From the document itself it looks as though the Bank’s forecast for growth this year and next is a sluggish 1% (it is difficult to be precise as the numbers are published only in the form of a small green chart). The autumn economic forecast of the EU Commission from the week before was even gloomier: Brussels sees UK growth next year at a meagre 0.6%.

One of the key repercussions of slower than anticipated growth in this country will be the impact on our debt arithmetic. This was already looking rocky over the summer. Although the numbers have improved since and we are currently in line with this year’s fiscal targets, the Office for Budget Responsibility is carrying this warning on its website at the time of writing:

Public sector net borrowing was £7.5 billion lower in the first six months of the fiscal year than in the same period of 2010-11. We would need a slightly bigger fall in the second half to match our March forecast of a £122 billion deficit for the year as a whole. In March we forecast that there would be a bigger fall in the second half, but prospects clearly depend in part on wider developments in the economy.

This is not surprising when we consider that their March forecasts were based on assumed GDP growth of 1.7% for this year and 2.5% next. Tax receipts of £588.6bn this fiscal year were projected to rise in line with nominal GDP; losing growth of 1.5% therefore equates to revenue loss of £8.8bn. At the same time, there could be slippage on the expenditure side too. (March’s numbers were based on claimant count unemployment of 1.55m this fiscal year, for example; the current level is 1.6m. And let’s not even think how much extra cash might have to be raised to support our banks in the event of an Italian or Spanish default.)

It is also the sad fact that Britain is not facing these challenges from a position of strength. The budget deficit for this year was forecast to be 7.9% of GDP, and 6.2% for 2012-13. In reality these numbers could look more like 8%+ and 7%, pushing our debt to GDP ratio (on a Maastricht basis) close to 90%. And the March budget envisioned balancing the books no earlier than 2016-17; revised borrowing numbers could push that estimate even further into the future.

There is something of a silver lining in that growth fears are keeping commodity prices contained, and this, coupled with continued weak demand, should see less erosion of wealth and income by inflation. Nonetheless, should the bond market lose confidence in us this would be cold comfort.

Most worrying on this front has been the treatment meted out to France in recent days. Speculation has been mounting that her AAA rating is threatened by – in Reuters’ colourful phrase – “being sucked into a debt spiral” as the economy slows. Ten year French bond yields have risen from 3.1% to 3.6% this month, as compared to 2% in Germany and 2.3% here. And yet compare France’s debt arithmetic to Britain’s: new austerity measures announced only a few days ago are forecast to see a budget deficit of 5.7% of GDP this year fall to 4.5% in 2012. French debt to GDP was 82% last year, in line with ours (80%). French growth is also forecast to be 0.5%-1% next year. In other words, France has stronger debt fundamentals than the UK. But it is France that has been singled out by markets for a beating.

It would appear that Britain’s non-membership of the eurozone is getting us a lot of credit. And given the state of our national finances, we need as much of that as we can get.

Advertisements

Entry filed under: Posts. Tags: , , , , , , , , , .

The Alternative Moving On

3 Comments

  • 1. Two Futures « The Blog @ Vigilant Financial  |  09/12/2011 at 10:31 am

    […] Short term developments could transform the picture, of course. The commitment to extend the IMF’s firepower might entice reserve-rich countries (read: “China”) to make similar commitments. On the other hand, the ratings companies are seeking ever more creative ways to compete for credibility while worsening the panic. S&P has threatened to cement its US rating debacle with a raft of eurozone sovereign downgrades. In reply, Moody’s zeroed in on the financial sector and downgraded some French banks this morning. Even Fitch played a clever oblique stroke last week by warning over the solvency of the UK (who’d have thought it?) […]

  • 2. Silver Lining « The Blog @ Vigilant Financial  |  16/12/2011 at 1:44 pm

    […] month this blog observed that falling inflation by way of lower commodity prices might constitute a rare silver lining to […]

  • 3. Bump In The Road « The Blog @ Vigilant Financial  |  27/01/2012 at 1:31 pm

    […] of England in the form of more “quantitative easing“. Nor does it alter the fact that the UK’s debt burden is an ugly one and that we have been lucky so far in that bond markets have given us the benefit of the doubt. […]

Trackback this post


Recent Posts